I'm not sure. Here's the things I see as important--

There are actually 8 more Stargazers than Cool Breezes.

However, a few more Cool Breezes get caught every Spring Festival, while the existing Stargazers are all the Stargazers there will ever be.

Yuehua Ma has two Vis, while your Cool Breeze has one.

However, your Cool Breeze has Swirling Snowflakes, one of the newest Nephini traits.

Since you've been playing Sylestia almost a year longer than I have, you probably have more experience pricing pets than I have. Have I summed it up pretty well?

Anyone reading this, can you contribute information? How can we compare prices between an extremely scarce Nephini Theme to a never-to-be-repeated Nephini Theme?

Actually, if they ever run the anniversary wheel again, potentially there could be more stargazers, still it's unlikely that any growth in the number of stargazers will match the growth in cool breeze nephs, long term.

So my advice would be....... Give the stargazer to Castielle! Actually I have no idea. just thought I'd mention the possibility of the wheel.

That's a good point about the Wheel; I had not thought of that. Any idea what's a reasonable sale price for a 2-Vis Stargazer? Ace has the Cool Breeze for public sale at 9 million gold, but I don't know if that's a placeholder or not.

Ace? If somebody offered you X amount of gold for the CB Neph, what "X" would you accept?

Id prefer 5mil+ but honestly im not sure.
And about the festival, I think since CB has been repeated twice, it wont be again. But that is just an assumption.
Pricing isnt really my forte, honestly.

I'm trying to remember how much mine was set for when I got him..... I think it was around ten million, but it's really up to you to decide what you'd be willing to accept. If I were to put my harvest day neph up for sale (2 vis) I'd probably price her at about 12 million and bargain with anyone who was interested. (There are 8 less than the stargazers, and I'm not sure if there will be more in the future)

OK, I think we're getting somewhere. Why don't we treat them as equivalent with regard to Theme? Then all we have to figure out the price difference between 2-Vis and 1-Vis.

Castielle, I don't mean to rope you into this conversation, but I thought you might be interested.

Typically I'd say it would be about 2 million- 4.5 million difference, or so. (Or that's about the difference I've noticed) not really sure though XD

I Purchased a cb neph 1 vis exclusive which is what that is for 700k

Others were selling around 1-1.5 mill and quite a few for sale during the fest.

(Btw this pricing is based on forums, not public sales. Forums tend to be cheaper than public sale prices, and things do sell off public sale at those higher prices)

SG's, at the time, were selling for 2-3k+ in diamonds and very hard to get a hold of. I saw 2 or 3 even go for between 7k- 8k diamonds.

Tagged pets are never worth what they originally were at the time of initial release from my experience unless you find someone who just absolutely has to have it.

Here is an example: last year when the BI nephs were first released, I struggled to find anyone to sell for 1.5k- 2k diamonds and ended up buying one for 3-3.5k diamonds (can't remember exactly). This year I got her a mate for 500 or 700 diamonds (again can't remember exactly) then won another BI myself from plant wars. Many people sold their BI nephs this year for around 1k diamonds. Huge difference over last year.

Should the CB and BI nephs be released again next year, their value will be dragged even further down. But of course, there is no gurantee that they will be released again.

Unless a significant number of SG nephs are won off the wheel this year (should it return), their value will not drop significantly, especially when considering that the SG nephs are one of the most popular themed neph designs. But to put it in perspective, only one or two of most tagged pets were won for specific themes off the wheel last year. (Most, there are always exceptions)

With that being said though, valuation of the CB in question of course is at the discretion of the seller and with things like trait disruptors (if they have been used) factored in, may in fact make the pet more valuable to the seller.

It also comes down to how badly you want the pet compared to how much you want to keep what you have and vice versa.

Hopefully this helps you make a more educated decision on how to value things. Not trying to sway anyone here or diminish the worth of anything. These are just my observations being a tagged neph collector myself.

And remember, if you really really want it, value kind of goes out the window. (Coughs at the almost 28 mill she spent on a tagged neph (but it was totally worth it and I'd do it again if I had to))

Ace, how about this? We swap even, but you give me 6 free breedings of my choice with your Themed Nephs? I have to find the other parent if I don't own her/him; I can't ask you to breed two of yours to each other and give me the egg.

I think thats fair.
but i'd also happily let you breed any of my two together, so you dont have to go to the trouble of finding a mate. ^^*
A lot of my pairings can produce pretty high traits. (:
I'l set my girly up for you then? (: