"Then how can I know?" Wolfstar asked

''you don't notice how different she is, do the shadows ring a bell'' she hissed

"Why can't they leave her alone!" Wolfstar growled bitterly. "I want her but she won't be left alone by outsiders."

''the shadows think its fair to take her because your kin took something of theres'' ivyfrost mewed

"Who took what?" Wolfstar asked then thought of Shadowkill.

''if your thinking about shadowkill then yes....he took a kit from them'' she answered

"Who?" Wolfstar asked

''a rouge clan... if you attack petalfall till shes almost dead the shadow will leave'' ivyfrost whisperd

"If I can save her then I will." Wolfstar said. "But what will happen if I do it now? How many lives does Tigerstar have left?"

''1....if you can get petalfall to follow you , you can then attack her'' she mewed and disappeared